Being a leader is one thing. Being a good leader is another. Being a great leader? Well…one thing is for certain. You better damn sure know how to set boundaries. AND you better damn sure know how to break them.
Those two things are not opposites. In fact – – – I believe they are part of the same discipline.
A Boundary Maker knows where the lines are AND more importantly, why they exist. They establish standards, expectations, values, responsibilities and rules of engagement. They make clear what is acceptable AND what is not. Boundary Makers create clarity. They protect the team from chaos by saying: This is who we are. This is how we operate. This is what we will tolerate. AND this is what we will not. Without boundaries – – – you don’t have freedom. You have confusion.
;BUT/THEN…there is the Boundary Breaker.
A Boundary Breaker sees the line, understands the line AND also recognizes that sometimes the line has become more important than the mission. They challenge assumptions. They question the way things have always been done. They push against bureaucracy, convention, comfort, precedent AND sometimes authority itself. Not because they are rebellious but because they are responsible.
There is a massive difference between breaking boundaries because you don’t like being told what to do and breaking boundaries because the mission requires something different.
If you send Jim Gant in on a mission, you best understand something before you send me: I am probably going to break some boundaries to accomplish the mission. If you don’t want boundaries broken – – – send someone else. Seriously. Why? Because I have spent most of my life looking at a problem and asking, What actually needs to happen here? Not, What are we normally allowed to do?
;BUT/AND – – – there is a catch. A huge one.
If you are going to break the rules, you damn sure better KNOW THE RULES.
You better know why they exist. You better understand what they’re protecting. You better understand the second and third-order consequences of crossing them. Most importantly – – – you better be willing to own the consequences when you do. Boundary breaking without competence is stupidity. Boundary breaking without accountability is arrogance. Boundary breaking without principles is recklessness. Boundary breaking without trust is mutiny. BUT boundary breaking grounded in competence, character, trust and mission? That IS leadership.
And here is where this gets uncomfortable for people like me.
If you are a Boundary Breaker yourself, what happens when somebody underneath you breaks one of your boundaries? Especially when it works?
Think about that for a minute. You told them how you wanted something done. They did NOT do it your way. They crossed the line. They challenged your thinking, ignored the process, took the risk – – – AND/THEN – – – accomplished the mission.
Now what?
Do you celebrate the initiative you claim you want or do you punish the disobedience because it threatened your control? That question will tell you a hell of a lot about yourself as a leader.
It is easy to call yourself a Boundary Breaker when you’re breaking someone else’s boundaries. It is much harder when somebody is breaking yours.
Great leaders don’t just tolerate initiative when it looks exactly like their own. They build people capable of exercising judgment without them. That requires trust and trust requires boundaries. There’s the paradox. Set the boundary clearly enough that people know when they’re crossing it. Build them well enough that they understand why it exists. Trust them enough to act when circumstances change. Hold them accountable enough to explain why they crossed it. AND when they were right, have the humility to say, “Good call.”
I want people around me who understand Commander’s Intent. Know the mission. Know the principles. Know the rules. Know the boundaries. ;AND/THEN – – – think. Because I do NOT want compliance machines. I want leaders.
The worst organizations I have ever seen have plenty of rules and very little trust. The best have clear boundaries AND enormous freedom inside them. And the truly great ones occasionally produce people wise enough, courageous enough and accountable enough to recognize when the mission requires them to step outside.
So which are you? A Boundary Maker or a Boundary Breaker?
Hopefully, you are becoming BOTH.
Because leadership requires the wisdom to know where the line belongs, the discipline to hold it when it matters, the courage to cross it when necessary and the humility to let someone else cross your line when they are right.
Know the rules. Know the mission. Know yourself. Know your team – – -Then lead.
Think on these things.
Together WE Transform – – – always, ALWAYS TOGETHER
My last class as an Unconventional Warfare instructor…what a time. What a time. What a time.





Resounding.
My brother…good to see your name…so good to remember you and your men. You guys were amazing…and still are my heroes.
Thank you…for all you did.
Love you – – – always.
Jim,This resonates deeply with me, not only as an idea about leadership, but through the experience of service and the realities of working in the field.Throughout my military experience, I learned that understanding a commander’s intent is often more important than mechanically following the wording of an order. The field rarely unfolds exactly as planned. Terrain changes, circumstances shift, time becomes critical, and decisions must sometimes be made before guidance can reach those responsible for acting.But there is an essential distinction: breaking a boundary is not, by itself, evidence of leadership. The real test is whether a person understands the mission, the principles behind the rules, the conditions on the ground, and the consequences of the decision—not only its immediate result, but also its second- and third-order effects.This is why I believe leadership must develop through a continuous process: Field, Observation, Experience, Analysis, Principle, Doctrine, Strategy, Practice, Outcome, and Feedback.A leader’s responsibility is not simply to create people who can execute instructions. It is to develop people who can understand, judge, act, and remain accountable when circumstances change.There is also a difficult responsibility on the other side: a leader must have the humility to recognize when someone else’s judgment has revealed something that his own perspective missed.Your distinction between boundary-setting and boundary-breaking raises an important question: Are we developing people who merely know where the boundaries are, or people who understand their purpose well enough to exercise sound judgment when the mission demands something different?Thank you, Jim, for bringing this discussion back to the realities of leadership, trust, and responsibility. I have great respect for your experience and for the service behind these reflections.Wahidullah Noorzai
Wahid,
You are doing great work.
Keep it up…